My KDP Select experiment is over

The SearchOn Sunday, December 9th, The Search ended its run in KDP Select. Here is my take on the requirements and/or “benefits” of placing your book in Amazon’s program.


Amazon requires that you do not offer your book in any digital format (you can still sell the physical copies) during your enrollment which lasts 90 days unless you re-enroll. (Note they automatically re-enroll you unless you deselect that option.)

My take….Most of my sales of my other books do come from Amazon so limiting my short story to the largest e-book retailer out there really didn’t bother me. But I am a firm believer that you shouldn’t put all your “eggs in one basket” and that part of selling a self-published work is to have a lot of exposure, which would dictate you have the books on Barnes and Noble, iTunes and the Kobo store.


While enrolled in KDP Select, you receive five days in which you can offer your novel at no cost as a marketing attempt to gain readers. (Is free worth it? Check out my post on that topic.)

My first free promotion, done 11 days after The Search was released, resulted in 119 downloads. I did this on a Thursday and Friday with very little promotion.

For my second free promotion which ran Nov. 29 to Dec. 1 (Thursday to Saturday), I did a lot more promoting. I started planning my promotion about three and a half weeks in advanced. I submitted my information to 14 different websites though I never did check to see which ones listed it on their sites. I also posted my free book on various Goodreads groups and the World Literary Café free boards.

I joined the tweet teams on World Literary Café and posted it on my blog, which meant my tribemates on Triberr all tweeted about it for me. And I was featured on two different blogs that were both run by some great people who promoted my free book on numerous Facebook pages as well as through their own Triberr/Twitter connections.

So needless to say, I had a LOT more promotion this time, and it paid off. On day one, I had 50 downloads – a slow day but I have heard that it takes awhile for the word of your free book to get out there. On day two, I had 691 downloads and then on the final day I only had 187. That is a total of 928 downloads. Now I know that for some they do that number in a day but for me, I am quite pleased with this promotion. Even if only 10% read my short story that is 92 new readers.

Now I had hoped to crack the top 100 free but the closest I came was #280. However, I did make it to the #2 on the Young Adult/Fantasy Free list. I never really meant for The Search or my trilogy to be marketed in the Young Adult category but have had several reviewers place it in that category, so I figured a little marketing to that group couldn’t hurt and it seems to have paid off. ranking blog

My take….Whether these free promotions are worth it is hard to say but I have had an increase in the sales of my other novels. In the first 2 days after my promotion ended, I sold 5 more copies of The Search plus 18 of my other novels. For me that is a personal best in such a short time.

I will say since Amazon allows this feature, they make it easy to offer a free promotion. All it takes is clicking “Manage promotions” on your KDP bookshelf and entering the dates you want the book free. If you aren’t a part of KDP Select, it is much harder to do this type of promotion (but not impossible).


Amazon touts that you will receive a share of their allotted money when people borrow your book as part of their Lending Library for Amazon Prime members. This month they have added a $700,000 bonus to the standard $700,000 usually allotted for paying authors in KDP Select who have their books borrowed.

My take….Well, I only had two people borrow my book (and these came after this last free promotion). I really hadn’t expected to have anyone borrow my short story which is only priced at 99 cents. I know that if I had Amazon Prime I would be using my one-a-month borrow on full-length novels over short stories.

I decided not to re-enroll The Search in KDP select and as of December 10th, it is available on Smashwords and soon will be distributed to the other e-book retailers.

Do I regret trying KDP Select? No, not at all. Will I do it again? Well, that depends on what they are offering at the time but right now, I am leaning toward no, I won’t do it for my next novel.  Can it be worth it for some authors? Sure, it can. If it is your first novel, I don’t think it is much help since a “free” promotion is of little benefit (see the above referenced post on free books). But if you have written many books and want to feature either your latest work or perhaps an older one, I can see the benefits of it.

4 thoughts on “My KDP Select experiment is over

  1. Jane says:

    Very good feedback for other Authors. Me? I’m a voracious reader and downloaded The Search immediately (the cat face did it, I’m afraid – as well as the synopsis). But(!) I am only “young at heart”, and I immediately downloaded all three of the following books. I became so intrigued with the entire idea of “saving the land” (something we need to do SO much!) . The stories (and the entire series) were very worthwhile reads – the characters well written, dialogue – important to me – completely descriptive. I did find several “transcribing” errors, which I always report to Amazon. I do not feel Authors deserve to be “denegrated” by spelling errors and simple lack of interest by what can only be the transcriber him/herself. Perhaps this problem could be aleviated by having transcribers only work on those books with actually interest them? Who knows!

  2. kizzylee says:

    thank you for sharing this i have been unsure about whether or not to join the kdp i am with createspace on amazon so obviously it is mentioned but i wasn’t keen for a number of reasons and hearing of your experience wgives me more information to work with, i still haven’t made my mind up but thank you very much for helping me see more clearly and your experience makes valuable reading for me ‘ have a great day xx

  3. ebookbuilders1 says:

    I think the idea of Select is good in theory and it can benefit new authors as wells as ones with a large catalog. When it was first announce, we encouraged our clients to take advantage of the program. One non-fiction author that we handle did amazingly well on his free promotion – with over 2000 downloads of a non-mainstream, non-fiction title with no promotion other than tweets by myself and on the other twitter accounts I manage.

    That being said, we are no longer advising our clients to use Select until such time as the issues that many authors are having with reviews and the high-handed treatment directed at a individual that questions why a review was removed. We are advising that the authors submit to as many online retailers as possible.

    I do think it was a wonderful opportunity for authors to expose their manuscripts to a wider audience, however the market has reached saturation point and should level off before I think it would be a worthwhile promotional tool.

    Thanks for posting your experiences, I am sure that other authors appreciate your openness and willingness to share..

  4. Beduwen says:

    I also appreciate you sharing your experience….the more info we authors have the easier it is to make informed decisions!

Leave a Reply to ebookbuilders1 Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s